You don't have javascript enabled. Please Enabled javascript for better performance.

Case Study: MyGov enabling participative decision making – Budget 2015

13 Mar 2015

budget_my-gov

Noted social activist Michael Moore was at his pithiest best while summing up the essence of democracy: “Democracy is not a spectator sport, it’s a participatory event. If we don’t participate in it, it ceases to be a democracy.”

While commentators have, over the centuries, debated the multiple benefits of democracy over other forms of governance, it is its participatory nature that has almost unanimously been recognised as the most outstanding feature. Democracy, in its normative form, while electing a leader through a transparent process, expects that leadership to make decision making a participative process where citizens have an important pro-active voice in policy making. But what is it about participative leadership that makes it so attractive?

First, involvement in decision-making improves the understanding of the issues involved by those who must carry out the decisions. This means the actual effect of the policy is factored in at the stage of policy making itself thereby insulating it from remaining a mere academic exercise.  Second, people are more committed to the actions flowing from the policy where they have been involved in the relevant decision-making. The citizens, who will actually be affected by the policy, have become a stake holder in the policy so framed rather than it being handed top down, and thus have more stakes in making the policy work.  Third, people are less competitive and more collaborative when they are working on joint goals. Fourth, when people make decisions together, the social commitment to one another is greater and thus increases their commitment to the decision.

Mahatma Gandhi, one of the greatest personalities of twentieth century, was among the first to understand the power of such participative decision making process to mobilize public opinion and this is what contributed to his enormous achievement of converting the freedom movement into a mass movement. Prime Minister Narendra Modi, inspired by the great Mahatma, has often spoken of learning from this great heritage and deploying it in modern context of converting the development and governance paradigm into a mass movement.

It is with this ambition that MyGov was launched by the Prime Minister on 26th July 2014 as a citizen online engagement platform. The avowed aim of the platform was to achieve the following purposes: A) Pro-active citizen participation in policy making; B) Citizen participation in governance tasks; and C) Volunteer participation to achieve synergy in the ideas and discussions in online world with action on the ground.

One of the conscious decisions taken during the conception stage of MyGov platform was to have no activity on MyGov without a buy-in by a relevant department or ministry of the government of India. This was done to ensure that all discussions and tasks on MyGov would have a defined closure point and therefore the valuable time that citizens spend on MyGov would be tied up with a clearly defined proposed action of the government. This way, MyGov would become a useful platform for citizens, retaining the flavour of a free flowing online general discussion forum, while avoiding the trap of only remaining a discussion forum.

This conceptual clarity at the level of the head of government, with a clearly defined mandate to ministries and departments to factor-in the citizen suggestions in discussions and tasks they have initiated on MyGov, in the eventual policy, program or schemes they frame, has resulted in much success for MyGov since its launch. The names of the very popular Pradhan Mantri Jan-Dhan Yojana and the now ubiquitous logo for the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan were generated by contributors on MyGov.  The Prime Minister himself has used the MyGov platform to regularly source citizens’ ideas and aspirations for his very popular, monthly “Mann ki Baat” dialogue with citizens.

The confidence generated by these early successes encouraged both ministries and the citizens to engage in crowd sourcing for even broader participation. The Ministry of Railways and the Ministry of Finance, thus initiated discussions seeking ideas from citizens for consideration for the Railway Budget and the General Budget respectively. In what was clearly a first, crowd sourced ideas from citizens, generated on MyGov, became actual government proposals in the respective budgets for the year 2015-16. The implications of a direct platform for citizens, where they could articulate their aspirations and needs to the government, without any intermediary or middlemen, can be seen in some of the far reaching ideas that became actual budget proposals.

For the Railway Budget, suggestions that have been incorporated in the actual proposals include proposals to fit bio-toilets and vacuum toilets in rail coaches to improve cleanliness; providing concessional e-tickets to differently-abled passengers; provision to order food online at the time of booking of tickets through IRCTC; integrating popular private food chains with the pantry network of railways; installation of digital display networks on platforms to provide real time information to citizens and the involvement of ISRO for providing audio-visual warnings to passengers at unmanned level crossings by using geo-spatial technology. A more detailed description of MyGov user suggestions reflected as actual proposals can be read here.

In the General Budget for 2015-16, some of the innovative proposals that have been incorporated include the proposal to enable monetization of gold and launching of sovereign gold bonds; proposal to abolish wealth tax and simplify tax structures; special tax incentive for promotion of Yoga; proposal to make sharing of PAN number mandatory for cash transactions above a specified value; 100% tax benefit for contributions to Swachh Bharat fund; utilization of vast postal network for improving access to banking in remotest corners of India and the proposal to introduce a law to penalize non disclosure of foreign bank accounts and to tackle benami property holdings in India. A more detailed description of MyGov user suggestions reflected as actual proposals can be read here.

These suggestions were thought of by the citizens themselves. They are aspirational in nature in some cases and practical in others. A gold monetization scheme can have transformational affect on the economy. Integrating of popular food chains with rail pantry network and simultaneously enabling the citizens to order food online would, while appearing as simple suggestions, enormously change the passenger experience for those who are travelling by rail network.

The implications of such participative decision making process are enormous.  Development as a paradigm of general national discourse is a rather abstruse concept. However, if the broad long term governance framework can be converted into an easily identifiable specific time bound programs, with which the citizen can identify themselves in the immediate term, then it is easier to weave it into the national fabric.  The General budget each year is an important policy document of the government, detailing the framework by which the government intends to manage the economy in the medium to long term. However, what is in it for me in the next budget is the most pertinent question by citizens in the build up to each year’s budget. The art of socially and emotionally investing the people in the governance paradigm is to somehow interlink these two strains. With MyGov platform acting a bridge, the citizen now has not to wait till the end of budget process to find out what is in it for them but can pro-actively help in deciding what do they want from the budget. One simple exercise of participative decision making and the budget becomes not a government’s document alone but a document of the people. The emotional commitment gets built-in and the abstruse development paradigm is on its way to becoming a participative mass movement.  The platform that is enabling this is the MyGov platform, translating the vision of Prime Minister Narendra Modi into a reality.

Total Comments - 104

Leave a Reply

  • prabhat thakur - 5 years ago

    Very Good idea as The country is of 125 Crores People,difficult for any Govt to handle large no letters, a fast categorised,need based platform for Creative, Suggestive , griveance is a major step towards Minimum Govt. Maximum Govt. No Doubt the Citizens benefitted the most as it Seems but the real benefits is for GOvt To show Its omnipresence bsed on these feedback, Thank U for New beginning

  • Cherish raj - 5 years ago

    It is true. I am happy that you mentioned our contribution towards the budget…I promise that in future too I will keep sharing my knowledge for our nation’s growth

  • rajkumar pandey - 5 years ago

    ordinary citizens of the country are affected by harassment, delay, bribery and corruption whenever they are forced to encounter local or state or central government in daily life, but honble PM has not yet started any group/helpline on corruption free government machinery nor any suggestions invited nor any perceptible change in working of central ministries is visible. this is most important aspect of daily life, which mygov has not yet touched. are bjp leaders preventing Modiji on this?

  • pawan kumar maurya - 5 years ago

    This method our country of scholarship fund and administrative expenditure can be low than fiscal deficit & budget deficit can be low .

  • pawan kumar maurya - 5 years ago

    but this method in one problem is present that not give Naukari all student. This problem for decease some conditions…..After study …1 Who have a Naukari than that student is return scholarship (some conditions) 2 Who have not Naukari that student is serve to service ( Goverment contract base job like fellowship, internship. any contract job ….) and based on low salary.

  • pawan kumar maurya - 5 years ago

    In past B.R.Ambedkar had been awarded Baroda State Scholarship for post graduate in Columbia University New York. As Ambedkar was educated by the Princely State of Baroda, he was bound to serve it. He was appointed as Military Secretary to the Gaikwad. my thinking..this is right method of scholarship distribution. this system is reactive in our country. this method in scholarships fund can one time allocate and reuse because Student was bound to give service

  • ASIT KUMAR NAG - 5 years ago

    Savings on oil subsidy due to fall in oil price be utalised for increased allocation under the health sector for improving health facilities in rural and semi rural areas.Increased allocation may be made for providing solar lighting in common areas of remotely located villages.Providing toilet in all schools needs more fund allocation and panchayat participation for construction of toilets in rural schools be considered for speedy implementation of the program.Local MPs may monitor progress.

  • indira mishra - 5 years ago

    Government doctors stay usually more in administration work like billing the receipts, recommending the medicines to medicine companies ,all those works which one administration wing should function. they waste time on all these things, now a days doctors stay busy in entering profiles ,datas detail of the patient which is a so time wasting job, why cannot some computer technicians be appointed to deal all these works, all should come under control to be verified by the health ministry.

  • indira mishra - 5 years ago

    Arun jaitley has allocated 331.9 billion for health sectors.one thing many government hospitals lack all type of modern equipments.they just provide vitamins not antibiotics seriously even if we evaluate the cases in lakhs are getting pending to be sanctioned the money to the poor people who are below poverty line. How many get back their money? Central govt and state government employees used to get some beneficiaries if any majore expenses, majore operation they do.people prefer more private.

  • M K Arora - 5 years ago

    Sir,
    Without solution to Tax Terrorism in India,it is waste to talk about Make in India at Ground level,
    As per various studies,If paid honestly, Indians pays 55% of Income towards (Direct & Indirect )Taxes,that too without any benefit from Government
    More the common man pay taxes, more they are harassed by Income Tax department.Tax mechanism is highly impracticable and full extortive,it is responsible for compulsory corruption.
    Income Tax Deptt extortions should be eased for common man.